Extra 30% Off All Sale Styles

*Offer valid 10/27/25 through 11/19/2025 on sale-priced merchandise only. Discount taken at the time of purchase in stores, at JJILL.COM or via catalog. Discount not valid on previous purchases or gift card purchases and is exclusive of sales tax and shipping fees. No cash value.

Extra 30% Off All Sale Styles

*Offer valid 10/27/25 through 11/19/2025 on sale-priced merchandise only. Discount taken at the time of purchase in stores, at JJILL.COM or via catalog. Discount not valid on previous purchases or gift card purchases and is exclusive of sales tax and shipping fees. No cash value.

Free standard shipping valid on your online or catalog purchase of $150 or more after all discounts are applied, exclusive of taxes. Flat-rate and free shipping not valid on J.Jill retail purchases or on purchases for delivery outside the U.S. Charge assessed for Quick Delivery and Express Delivery. No cash value.

stores

Sofft® Carleigh Peep-Toe Booties

SOFFT® CARLEIGH PEEP TOE BOOTIE
sofft® carleigh peep-toe booties
Hover to ZoomLong-Touch to ZoomHover to Zoom
Sofft® Carleigh Peep-Toe Booties

Sofft® Carleigh Peep-Toe Booties

SOFFT® CARLEIGH PEEP TOE BOOTIE

$

146

COLOR:

light grey

$

146

SIZE:

QTY:

Save for Later >

Share This Product

Style No. 283721

WAYS TO STYLE
the Sofft® Carleigh Peep-Toe Booties


Reviews & Questions

Reviews

Rating Snapshot

Select a row below to filter reviews.
11 reviews with 5 stars.
9 reviews with 4 stars.
3 reviews with 3 stars.
6 reviews with 2 stars.
2 reviews with 1 star.

Overall Rating

3.7
13 out of 24 (54%) reviewers recommend this product

Review this Product

Select to rate the item with 1 star. This action will open submission form.
Select to rate the item with 2 stars. This action will open submission form.
Select to rate the item with 3 stars. This action will open submission form.
Select to rate the item with 4 stars. This action will open submission form.
Select to rate the item with 5 stars. This action will open submission form.
Adding a review will require a valid email for verification

Average Customer Ratings

Filter Reviews

1 to 8 of 31 Reviews
1 – 8 of 31 Reviews
Reviews 2
Votes 0

Very uncomfortable

5 months ago
This shoe is very uncomfortable - the seams are hard and rub terribly on my feet. I will be returning the pair.

No, I do not recommend this product.

Helpful?
Birmingham Alabama
Reviews 2
Vote 1
What size type did you buy?Regular
Age65 or over
How tall are you?5'3"-5'4"
Body TypeHourglass or Curvy

Uncomfortable

a year ago
Tight & hurt my ankle because of how stiff they are. I wanted to love them bc they’re so cute but too painful. Returning immediately.

No, I do not recommend this product.

Helpful?
North Georgia
Reviews 3
Votes 2
What size type did you buy?Regular
Age65 or over
How tall are you?5'3"-5'4"
Body TypeStraight or Rectangular

Disappointed!

a year ago
Had to send them back. Obvious flaw in the suede directly on top of one shoe. Very stiff leather that would’ve required a breaking in period. Too uncomfortable/inflexible around the ankles. Too bad, they’re super cute!

No, I do not recommend this product.

Helpful?
Review 1
Vote 1

Cute but stiff

a year ago
These are very cute however the suede upper is incredibly stiff.

No, I do not recommend this product.

Helpful?
Reviews 2
Votes 2
What size type did you buy?Regular
Age45 to 54
How tall are you?5'5"-5'6"
Body TypeApple, Full Bust & Body

Adorable but TOO Tight.

a year ago
I loved these so much, I bought them at full price. But I was shocked at how uncomfortable they are. I am a solid size 8 and these were incredibly tight on my feet. I am not wide width either. And there was not a lot of padding under the ball of the foot. They are adorable but TOO TIGHT. I returned them.

No, I do not recommend this product.

Helpful?
Las Vegas, NV
Reviews 3
Vote 1
What size type did you buy?Petite
Age55 to 64
How tall are you?5'-5'2"
Body TypeHourglass or Curvy

Great all around shoe

a year ago
This is my second pair of Sofft booties and I just love them! I live in the southwest so I can wear an open shoe most of the year. I bought the grey pair to pair with a purse & belt I have. I love this brand. The heel is not too high and the bootie looks great with either casual pants or a dress. I have them in a luggage color and plan on getting another pair in dark brown. They are comfortable, stylish and coordinate well with many things in my closet. Checks all the boxes!

Yes, I recommend this product.

Helpful?
Texas
Review 1
Vote 1
What size type did you buy?Regular
Age65 or over
How tall are you?5'-5'2"
Body TypeStraight or Rectangular

Makes your legs look better.

a year ago
Had shoes similar to these and was happy to find them again

Yes, I recommend this product.

Helpful?
Seattle, WA
Reviews 7
Votes 8
What size type did you buy?Regular
Age65 or over
How tall are you?5'5"-5'6"
Body TypeHourglass or Curvy

Unbelievably comfortable at first try on…

a year ago
…but as some other reviewers also noted, the top comes up to just high enough to where it cuts into your ankle above the instep. This hurt so much I couldn’t even stand up in them, let alone walk in them, so they went right back in the box and were returned. Will probably work for some, but not for me.

Yes, I recommend this product.

Helpful?
1 – 8 of 31 Reviews

NEED HELP?

© Jill Acquisition LLC. All Rights Reserved.

Terms of Use

Privacy & Security

Your Privacy ChoicesCalifornia Consumer Privacy Act (CCPA) Opt-Out Icon