Rated 5 out of 5 by JaneRN Soft supple leather great color
These are true to size, very soft and well
made. Worth the money and the grey is more
June 27, 2015
Rated 4 out of 5 by Mckimisah toe cleavage
Finally, a pair of J Jill shoes, that I think are beautiful, and actually fit my narrow feet! After reading the many reviews I thought it worth a try to order these shoes in my normal size, 8.5; they were too wide, by a small amount and a tad long, too. So I then ordered a size 8 and voila, I now own a beautiful pair of ballerina flats which are made well, are low cut which shows off a bit of toe cleavage and look so very feminine AND stylish. Stylish can be very hard (& expensive) to find for narrow feet. As another reader wrote, the heel actually runs narrow, so it stays on my foot! Yay! The only reason not five stars is that the size 8s have a couple scratches along the front and were not shipped in the frye shoe box as the first pair had been--probably someone else returned them. They were all sold out in this color when I rechecked to see if I could exchange them, so, I will keep them since I was able to purchase at a wonderful sale price.
June 17, 2015
Rated 2 out of 5 by QualityIsBetter Great style but too small. From my experience order a size bigger
The pair of shoes were a great quality and style. I really wanted these shoes to fit but as a true size 11 they were a bit of a disappointment. They were way too tight and uncomfortable and I did not want to sacrifice hurting my feet until the shoe could stretch more. Sadly, I had to return them and there is no size 12 at J Jill in this style. I still love the store and the quality of their products, and will continue to purchase from them in the future.
June 12, 2015
Rated 2 out of 5 by Caicos Manufacturer appears to have changed; quality poor
I bought a pair of these last year and absolutely loved them. So this year I bought the same style in a different color. This pair fits differently, and is obviously manufactured by a different vendor as the markings are placed differently. These feel like they are made of vinyl and not leather and now they are giving me blisters where the other pair did not. Very disappointed.
May 19, 2015
Rated 5 out of 5 by Joetie Love them so much I bought another color
I absolutely loved these flat Frye shoes. After reading another review, I ordered the gray. What a gorgeous color that turned out to be. It is more of a darker taupe and definitely not just a gray. These flats are a fantastic neutral for me. I wear a 7 in almost all shoes and the 7 in these fit me well, albeit a tiny snug, but because they are entirely leather, they have stretched some. I like the whole cut of these flats and how they made my feet look so I bought another pair in black. I may not be able to hold myself back from getting a third pair in cognac. : P
May 7, 2015
Rated 1 out of 5 by Lareitz Runs small
Had to return this item. Very cute shoe buy runs very small. Fit was tight all over.
April 28, 2015
Rated 5 out of 5 by Diana88 Better than expected!
I took the plunge and ordered these flats While starting out a bit snug - they have stretched just enough to fit my feet like the best leather glove! Soft and supple and the color is beautiful. I would recommend them but you need a bit of patience - wear them around the house to stretch out and then I found they were fine!
April 27, 2015
Rated 5 out of 5 by SmokiesSal Comfortable right out of the box!
These are lovely casual flats to wear with skirts or jeans. They fit beautifully, particularly the heel that is narrow enough to keep the shoes on my feet. The styling is casual and fun. The leather is thick and soft and I love the color. Extremely pleased with these shoes!
April 12, 2015