Rated 1 out of 5 by CatPA Change of design, exactly like smooth-fit
These sat slightly above my waist and the crotch was baggy. If I pulled them up like grandpa pants, the crotch was fine. The Authentic Fit I got the last time in the same size did not have elastic in the waistband and sat below my natural waist. They have been redesigned to be exactly like the smooth-fit that I returned two weeks ago. These are going back as well.
March 13, 2015
Rated 5 out of 5 by Junebug6 Comfortable fit!
These are one of my favorite jeans now! So comfortable with just a bit of stretch and a waist that stays up on my hips! Very slimming and I got them on sale! Thanks!
February 4, 2015
Rated 5 out of 5 by sandi111 Takes ten pounds off your legs!
I love, love, love these jeans. So comfy and slimming - I wish these were made in every color! Thank you, J.Jill, for another flattering style. You all really know your fashion!
January 1, 2015
Rated 5 out of 5 by Gaelpoet Glad I got these!
This cut is close to the body, while remaining classy. The narrowest legs of any J. Jill jeans I've purchased, yet the slight stretch makes them comfortable. Very on-trend! I love them!
December 27, 2014
Rated 5 out of 5 by JJillFan2 Perfect silhouette
Best J Jill jeans ever (and I've bought many many of them). Slim in the legs, more generous in the waist for all-day comfort. Love the bootcut silhouette. Overall, great fit. Makes me feel young!! PLEASE keep making these year after year, perhaps in different colors and fabrics.
A minor issue: some sizing inconsistencies. Of 5 pairs I bought (size 4), had to return two because one was 2 inches wider, the 2nd was an inch wider ...! (perhaps wrong labeling?) The remaining 3 were just right and they are what I rated here.
December 27, 2014
Rated 3 out of 5 by Mary617 Stiff fabric & button came off
These jeans are much stiffer than other J Jill jeans I've bought. I prefer a bit softer fabric, but some people might like this sturdier feel.
On the first day I wore these, the waist button came off (and yes, I'm wearing the correct size). That's disappointing as the button is a metal one that can't be sewn back on.
December 16, 2014
Rated 5 out of 5 by kibbe Awesome Fit
Authentic Fit Slim boot-cut jeans fit very well, and are so comfortable! In fact, I'm wearing them now. The stretch in the jean material helps the jeans retain their shape, i.e. no bagging after a few hours. For anyone interested in inseam...I'm 5'10", and the Tall is a great length for me (wearing 1"+ shoes). I would hem them an inch if I were to wear mostly flats with the jeans. As it is I have gotten away with wearing flats and had only minimal dragging. Love them!!!
December 10, 2014
Rated 4 out of 5 by Texbian Great looking and comfy!
I really like the fit and comfort of these jeans! Perfect for boots.
December 6, 2014