Rated 4 out of 5 by catmum Nice if you have read the reviews and know what you are buying
This shirt is designed to be very loose and flowing. It is very soft and silky (I was surprised by how high the cotton content was, given the feel of the fabric). It does not hug the body at all. It's great for someone like me who wants to conceal things, but I can see why it's gotten some mixed reviews. This is not a conventional, figure hugging t-shirt like it looks to be in the picture.
February 18, 2015
Rated 4 out of 5 by Kat1965 Big and baggy
Great JJill cotton but is big and baggy. I got it on sale so will keep it for lounging and sleeping.
February 13, 2015
Rated 1 out of 5 by Peeg Horrible.
I don't know what I received, but it was not the top shown on model. Worse design ever. makes you look overly huge. Seams are sewn on the outside, looks like you are wearing the top inside out. Awful!
February 1, 2015
Rated 5 out of 5 by teacup Ingenious tee!
I read some of the reviews before ordering this tee and was a little concerned about the criticism of the shape. I received this in black and removed it from the box to find it to truly be a simple shape, as mentioned in the remarks. However, when I tried it on, it looks amazing. It is true, I don't like my tees to be clingy, and tight, so I found this loose fit very comfortable and yet, the placement of the sleeve holes are perfectly placed so that this does not look like you are wearing a pillowcase! The shape of the bodice also creates a gradual flow to the bottom which makes for a nice looking fit. The thickness of the fabric is enough to wear without anything under and I look forward to reaching for this next spring and summer!
January 24, 2015
Rated 1 out of 5 by ellyg TERRIBLE!
THIS SHIRT LOOKS LIKE A SACK WITH ARM AND NECK HOLES. THE MATERIAL IS AWFUL - IT'S GOING BACK!
December 23, 2014
Rated 5 out of 5 by daisylover Fun little casual top
I know some people have said this is boxy and oversized and they don't like it, but I do! It is a square top, and it is oversized, but it's perfect over a pair of leggings with Ugg boots to just wear around the house, or throw a big cardigan over and go to the store! I've even worn it to work on those days when I have lots of work to do, don't need to see any clients, and want to be super comfortable. Not everything has to be fitted. This is a great little top!
December 20, 2014
Rated 5 out of 5 by MaryCatherine A Terrific Staple
I have this tee shirt in several colors - it is so comfortable and flattering! I love it with jeans and a cardigan or just over leggings. It is plenty long and generous in proportion, while maintaining a feminine silouette without being huge and dumpy. The colors are true wash after wash. This is a great go-to tee!
December 14, 2014
Rated 2 out of 5 by Elauna Not presented right
This is actually a poncho with no shape - basically a folded piece of fabric with the sides sewn down the edge of the fabric and openings left for armholes. I think it could have been photographed to show the construction. If you have the figure for it this could be attractive. My biggest problem with the XL is that it is really oversized and the neckline is huge. I seem to be having a problem with too large a neckline on several J Jill styles - maybe time for J Jill to think of the way things fit there.
On the plus side if you are expecting this style and order a size smaller than you normally wear you might love this as the fabric is lovely, soft and great quality.
December 10, 2014